Puzzle #1: Hint 4

This isn't really a new hint, it's just a more detailed version of the second one:

Once you have a list of possible ages, consider the fact that the visitor didn't know which was correct at this point (despite knowing her own age). But once she was told that only one tortoise was older than she, she knew the answer immediately.

Kevin Fink's Home Page (http://www.fink.com/Kevin.html)